The Boston Globe
August 30, 2002
"PHOTO' IS NOT A BEAUTIFUL PICTURE
by TY BURR
Robin Williams has a raging need for love that fuels his best work as
a comedian and his worst work as a film actor. It's the motor goosing
his awe-inspiring torrents of free association on a stand-up stage
that's behind such pathetic pap as "Patch Adams" and "Jacob the
Liar," and it's woven into Williams's performance as a lonely psycho
in "One Hour Photo," too. There are weird resonances between actor
and role here, and they're not exactly flattering. I think Williams
is aware of them. I hope he is, anyway.
Sy Parrish also desperately wants attention, but where the man
playing him found salvation by exploding outward, Sy curls in on
himself until he vanishes. He's "Sy the Photo Guy," the chipper,
bespectacled blur behind the SavMart photo counter - a man who takes
pride in his work, is courtly and solicitous to his clientele, and is
especially fond of the Yorkin family. And who wouldn't be? Husband
Will (Michael Vartan of TV's "Alias") is a trim, successful bohemian
yuppie. Wife Nina ("Gladiator" 's Connie Nielsen) is Pottery Barn
elegance personified. Son Jake (Dylan Smith) is the kid we wish we
had, or had been.
They are picture perfect, and that is why Sy has covered an entire
wall of his Spartan apartment with extra copies of their SavMart
snapshots. "One Hour Photo" takes off from the notion that it's
anonymous service-industry workers like Sy - the people who give us
change and are immediately forgotten - who are privy to the most
intimate moments of our lives. What if one of them decided he wanted
in?
Thriller fans might remember a terrific 1987 B flick called "The
Stepfather." "One Hour Photo" is that film, directed by an art
student. Actually, Mark Romanek has made music videos for Madonna and
R.E.M., but he slows the beat way down for his first feature and
bathes his sets in a sepulchral white. Every shot is precisely
framed, just as Sy might want, and eventually all the useless beauty
wears you down. The movie establishes from the outset that Sy is a
sad little nutcase and then it waits, and waits, and waits, for him
to pop his cork.
When he does, it's in unexpected ways and for unsuspected reasons. Sy
comes across photo evidence of Will's infidelity, and it sends him
into a prim fury; that and the tenderness with which he treats Jake
make it clear that he identifies with the boy in ways he can't quite
fathom. His revenge is deeply unnerving, all the more so for not
following the traditional stab-and-hack path.
It comes too late to save the movie, though, even if Williams gets
off a startling monologue at the very end that shines a sudden, cold
light into Sy's psyche. His performance is the main reason to
see "One Hour Photo," and, at that, only for the way it teasingly
reveals aspects of the actor while staying buried in character.
Williams uses his hesitant smile, his old gaffer's chin, the eyes
that shyly dart away and reconnect - the schtick with which he has
asked for our love in the past - and creates a man warped by his need
for love. For all the art, it's something of a confession.
© The Boston Globe
Back To One Hour Photo Articles